[IMC-Boston-Dispatch] Indy-Fundamentalism: Its Root Causes and Structure

[boreal_nymph at fastmail.fm]

Indy-Fundamentalism is a movement in turn-of-the-20th Century
Progressivism emphasizing the literally interpreted Indymedia Charter as
fundamental to Progressive life and teaching.  Indy-Fundamentalism also
refers to the beliefs of this movement, i.e. Indymedia, or the adherence
to those beliefs, or the manner of adhering to those beliefs.  It is a
movement or attitude stressing strict and literal adherence to a set of
basic principles, these being the Indymedia mission, points-of-unity and
structure.

Here we examine the Indymedia points-of-unity and structure and then
describe how these rules are strictly and fanatically applied as
Indy-Fundamentalism.

The Independent Media Center Mission Statement:

"The Independent Media Center is a global network of collectively run
media outlets for the creation of radical, accurate, and passionate
tellings of truth. We are motivated by a love and inspiration for people
who work for a better world despite corporate media's distortions and
unwillingness to cover efforts to develop an egalitarian and sustainable
society.

With autonomous chapters in more than 200 cities across the world, the
Independent Media Center network has become an international information
source for media activists. The IMC seeks to create a new media ethic by
providing progressive, in-depth, and accurate coverage of issues. We are
a community-based organization using media to facilitate political and
cultural self-representation. We seek to illuminate and analyze issues
impacting individuals, communities and eco-systems by providing media
tools and knowledge to those seeking to communicate.

The Boston Independent Media Center is a grassroots organization
committed to using media production and distribution as tools for
promoting social and economic justice in the boston Area. We are
dedicated to addressing issues that the mainstream media neglects and we
do not conceal our politics behind a false objectivity. We will empower
people to "become the media" by providing democratic access to available
technologies and information."

Examined: Indy-Fundamentalism strictly and fanatically applies the
following beliefs as imperatives:

IMC is a member-based organization.
IMC members participate in and evangelize/spread the global network of
collectivized media outlets.
IMC media outlets shall be radical (communist/anarchist) in nature.
IMC media outlets shall be accurate (biased) and the stories featured
shall be leftist passion plays.
IMC is motivated by love and creation of a better world (e.g. "another
world is possible").
IMC members must believe that other media outlets tell lies, and IMC
tells truth.
IMC insists that a media conspiracy exists whereby the egalitarian /
sustainable (socialist and ecoterrorist) movements are denied coverage.
IMC chapters are autonomous.
IMC is measured in quality by its quantity of franchises.
IMC is an activist information service.
IMC seeks to morally change the media to a Progressive set of ethics.
IMC is communal.
IMC is a facilitator of political and cultural self-representation. 
("Self" is not quantified by this organization).
IMC is an illuminated organization.
IMC analyzes issues on the basis of things happening to people against
their will, (e.g. why bad things happen to good people).
IMC is reflexive, and/or a reaction formation.
IMC is a tool and knowledge provider.
IMC is a promoter of social and economic justice. (e.g. of Jesuitical
Social Gospel).
IMC is not objective.
IMC is kingmaker of people deemed worthy of "becoming the media" (e.g. a
liason for siezing the means of production).

This body of beliefs/imperatives characterize the Indy-Fundamentalist as
a joiner, an evangelist, a minister of information, a collectivist,
communist-anarchist, an ESFP Meyers Briggs "Performer" type who
gesticulates, or an INTP "Mr. Spock Buddhist" type who rationalizes
altruism and sacrifice, and places "the needs of the many before the
needs of the one" unless of course he is the one, in which case he
shifts to egalitarian mode.  The Indy-Fundamentalist either writes
stories reminiscent of passion plays or Henrik Ibsen existentialist
plays which are then passed off as criticisms of "this world" and pleas
for a more idealistic world.  The leap from the one world to the other
is often impossible, irrational, or requires some form of sublimated
mass upheaval on a fated day of Rapture in the indeterminate future.

The Indy-Fundamentalist has a collective criterion of truth, in other
words, what is decided by long division at the lowest common denominator
across the largest group (or the largest group present) is the TruthTM. 
Woe unto he who challenges the "truth told passionately."  These
Fundamentalists are the protagonists of the passion play, or the Chorus
relaying the moral lesson of the tragedy of life (cliche) as the
underprivileged masses either cannot articulate, or as they themselves
as agents of the underprivileged (via transferrence or skin or genital
privilege) do articulate.  Failure of the mainstream media to cover
these passionate performances owes to the evil capitalist conspiracy to
oppress them and then hide the oppression.  Ergo, the secret and devious
hand of the white-male-employed-capitalist-anglophone-Satan was set
against them, and they are merely retaliating on behalf of morality.

The morality is of course Progressivism or rather International
Socialism, as distinct from the autarchic, progressive nationalist,
conservationist ideas of The Progressive Party of Teddy Roosevelt. 
Thus, it is a decadence progressivism, a ressentiment progressivism, a
reactive, homosexualized, vegetarianized Marxism, loosely stilted upon
the Kantian Categorical Imperative, Hegelian Historical Dialectical
Materialism, and Platonism.  There is also an unhealthy dose of
anti-materialism, and a rejection of the principles of biological health
and commercial success.  Successful individual endeavors and robust
claims or prominence of individuals are deemed suspicious, as they would
be in a cult such as Scientology, Communist Party USA, Mormonism, or the
Jehovah's Witnesses.  Embedded in this morality is also the Puritan
Ethic, Protestant Iconoclasm, and again Scientology, as the adherents to
Indy-Fundamentalism are engaged in a constant purge of charisma,
free-thought, taboo ideas, and financial well being from their commune
and its prospective members.  As distinct from Scientology however, "bad
engrams" are not brainwashed out, but rather transmuted into accusations
against "society" hence its appeal to young people.

Thus is the Indy-Fundamentalist organization incapable of actually
facilitating political and cultural self-representation.  So, it resorts
to a two pronged pathway of rationalizing, and cultural appropriation. 
The rationalization process is characterized by the incessant purge of
new ideas, and the laying of blame of failure upon evil social forces. 
The cultural appropriation process is characterized by role reversals
and thefts such as whites acting as revolutionary blacks, men acting as
battered women, women acting as oppressed minorities and rape victims,
college students acting as Zapatistas, Americans acting as Native
Americans, and Jews acting as Palestinians.   The open travesty of such
behavior requires constant camouflage which feeds the evangelical
portion of the movement which has adopted Affirmative Action, and thus
constantly seeks melanin and estrogen infusions in the form of new
recruits and a constant self-deprecation and self-depredation of one's
whiteness, one's rich Jewish parents, one's prep or Ivy League school. 
The passion play must be performed constantly in the form of protests
and the coverage of the protests, and the censorship of the ridicule of
the protests.  One is reminded of puppet shows at the Temple Emanu-El,
or bad street performances by musicians in training.

As for the autonomy of the local Indy-Fundamentalist franchise, (church,
infoshop, cell, or node,) this is rebutted by the Approval Process which
is a function of the International, which is a reduplication of the
Master Node which is the IMC main node, whose religious Year Zero began
at the Seattle WTO Protests.  The network of Indy-Fundamentalist
franchises are largely centralized on a few key servers, many of which
house several if not whole swaths of "independent autonomous nodes"
whose information is cross-syndicated, and whose secretive editorship
all use the Master's clandestine networking service.  The Master of the
franchise is of course a lecturer, a power point presenter and
self-promoter with feet firmly rooted in the Capitalist world.  The
quantity-as-quality criteria of Indy-Fundamentalism is thus bunk, as it
is a cloning / droning phenomenon save for the fact that the individual
franchises are staffed by locals whose cloned opinions and beliefs were
harvested and outfitted by, and not manufactured by the Master node. 
The autonomy is also besmirched by the node for node facilitation of the
same bodies of anarcho-communist groups by and on every IMC, and their
editorial membership overlaps.

IMC, like an anti-capitalist Amway, is a mechanism for
self-representation.  But the sense of self is lacking and manifests as
a cult-of-no-personality, with core members sabotaging one another and
dragging one another down in various bids for micropower.  IMC's
network-self is thus subject to easy sabotage.  "Self" is an eigenvalue
within Indy-Fundamentalism which consists of the "self-identified"
activist merged with the "anti-hierarchical" activist.  Thus is
Indy-Fundamentalism manifested as an endless constructive-deconstructive
act and zero sum game.  Activists self-identify as activist factions and
then rapidly self-unidentify or self-disassociate / apostasize from the
other homogenous but hyphenated subgroups engaged in the pathetic
struggle to control a portion of free serverspace allocated to the IMC
local node.  Thus the communal notion is refuted, though the
infrastructure of a sovietized website remains for whichever subgroup +
technician muscles it away from the others.  Whichever subgroup controls
the node becomes the core group of Indy-Fundamentalists, and its choice
of propaganda becomes the Illuminated Thought or mutually agreed upon
corn pone opinion du jour. 

Whether this constitutes "Information"  is a matter of debate within the
current cabal, but in terms of Shannon Information Theory, it
constitutes Information when the signal-to-noise-ratio permits discrete
signals to be processed by the readers.  Much of the content of an IMC
is noise, in the form of phentermine ads, links to noise blogs, links to
disinfo blogs where signal is deliberately mixed with noise about 9/11
conspiracies, and space aliens.  Qualitatively the information on an IMC
is largely an echo or mirror of information on other IMCs, which leaves
the heavily formatted, heavily and viciously dumbed down inflammatory
info signals of approximately two editors and four local
anarcho-communist groups, all of whom believe some hybrid of their own
organization's dogma, and the tenets of Indy-Fundamentalism.

The idea that this largely dirty Information source is "illuminated"
implies that the providers of this noisy signal are themselves a form of
Enlightened Beings.  One must forgive the hubris of an Ivy League
education.  The "enlightened beings" who write the passion plays of
Indy-Fundamentalism come across as tepid and dim-witted reactionaries. 
Though their texts are heavily embroidered, none of them have mastered
the techniques of fine calligraphy or binding associated with monastic
republication.  Their explication as to why bad things happen to good
people (themselves, or the reform chosen), thus lacks the majesty of a
sacred book, but this is of course a high handed criticism. 
Indy-Fundamentalism is a chandala religion, bargain basement mass
morality which ranks somewhere below Zack De La Rocha or Serj Tankian's
angry and emotional vocal riffs and screeches, and far less musical. 
They are expected to suck, and suckiness is the criteria by which they
distinguish themselves from the federal agents they believe have
infiltrated their toasters, bugged their lunch boxes, and financed every
criticism of their organization.

The last tenets of Indy-Fundamentalism can be rolled together, namely
the exclusive claim to be promoters of the right way of thinking in
their immediate community.  How many of these do we have in Boston? 
Many.  We have Nuwabians, ISKON, Scientology, Hillel House, Church of
Christ, The Christian Science Mother Church, and all of these within the
few narrow blocks spanning Newbury Street to Columbus Avenue.  They
range from cults of relative acceptance to 503 c) nonprofit scams, but
of them all, Indy-Fundamentalists claim to promote social and economic
justice while at the same time claiming to promote and demote members of
the community at large to status of media personnel, and with a
borrowed, begged, stolen and mostly tenuous infrastructure.

The Independent Media Center Structure:

Listservs:  There are seven: Announce, Discuss, Dispatch, Editorial,
Tech, Radio, Video. Due to low staffing, most of these are peopled by
the same 3 to 5 individuals, and each node has at best one technician
who maintains the site and migrates it across servers.  The Discuss
lists are for planning. The Dispatch lists are for fielding third party
submissions, to which if you are identified as non-Indy-Fundamental, you
will be blocked from submitting.  Tech is for maintaining the site,
usually migrating it to another free server, fixing it, or instating
various censorship protocols, such as user or keyword blocking. 
Editorial is where the IMC editors fight and complain about one another
and their readership or critics, and plan their frivolous lawsuits and
protests.  In the case of Boston IMC, the Editorial discussions were
made private, after openness had been deemed a serious liability to
their kingmaking and consensus manufacturing abilities.  The relevant
note to Indy-Fundamentalism was that the decision to hide their
organization's censorship and information control process from their
readership was deemed by the upper echelon to be within the guideline of
the IMC General Practice.  That is to say that several of the more
communist, anarchist, or eco-terrorist nodes such as the one in Chicago
have gone clandestine and closed, and thus there is a "growing
consensus" to hide the activity of IMC from the public.  The Radio /
Video lists represent outreach to Indy-Fundamentalist low wattage radio
and community access television stations in local left-leaning greater
metro areas.  In Boston, these are found in Cambridge, Somerville,
Allston, Jamaica Plain, (e.g. college ghettos) and on college campuses.

The Independent Media Points Of Unity:

This terminology has fallen out of favor, but essentially, the points of
unity are the same as International A.N.S.W.E.R. that all information
content and members must be anti-capitalist, anti-racist, feminist,
homosexual, and vegan at all times.  All members are equal, but
lesbians, latinos and blacks are more equal, though precious few -- if
none -- of them actually participate in the organization.  Also, any
statements which are deemed to be slanderous (critical) of
Indy-Fundamentalism are to be censored, though the word "censor" shall
not be used, in fact it too shall be censored.  Also any individuals who
have been censored shall be placed on probation and targetted for future
censorship, barred from membership, and barred from using the commons or
the "community" or its donated facilities if they did attempt to appeal
acts of censorship.  An individual barred from the community is
considered shunned, and memos shall be circulated across all tangent
communities to disenfranchise said blacklisted individual, generally
sink his boat, deny his venue, and shout down his duly paid for and
legally organized events.

At first glance, many of the weaknesses of the Indy-Fundamentalist
structure are self-evident, those being the same weaknesses of other
cults and totalitarian movements.  At second glance, one can see how the
members themselves take advantage of the structure, and how they
determine in from out.  At third glance, one can see core flaws in the
network which can be used to destroy it, harry it, or run down its
resources.  These flaws which involve reversing, counterbalancing, or
aggravating the list of IMC imperatives will be addressed in another
writing.
-- 
  
  boreal_nymph at fastmail.fm

-- 
http://www.fastmail.fm - Email service worth paying for. Try it for free