[Imc-beirut] Hezbollah in Canadian press. An interview with Ali Mallah of the Canadian Arab Federation.
tadamon at resist.ca
Fri Jul 11 15:42:15 PDT 2008
* Hezbollah in Canadian press
An interview with Ali Mallah of the Canadian Arab Federation.
In recent weeks, major media outlets in Canada have featured numerous news
reports on Hezbollah, outlining that the armed Lebanese political party is
planning military operations in North America. Media reports have been based on
anonymous intelligence sources in the U.S. and Canada.
Major media coverage in Canada was ignited by a T.V. report from the U.S.-based
ABC news network claiming that Hezbollah was planning operations in Canada in
response to the assassination of Hezbollah's military commander, Imad
Mughniyeh, in Syria this past winter.
Hezbollah formed in southern Lebanon in the mid 1980.s as an armed resistance
group to Israel's military occupation. Given Hezbollah's consistent focus on
engaging Israel as a foreign occupier or invading military force in Lebanon,
possibilities outlined in recent media reports on Hezbollah activities in North
America are highly unlikely.
In response to recent media reports on Hezbollah, the Arab community,
specifically Lebanese in Canada, fear a wave of unwelcome visits from the
Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS), similar to numerous unwelcome
visits in 2006 during Israel's bombardment of Lebanon.
Ali Mallah, an organizer with the Canadian Arab Federation, comments on the
recent wave of media reports in Canada and provides an alternative context to
mainstream media reports on Arabs and Muslims in Canada within the post 9/11
environment. Ali Mallah was interviewed for Tadamon! Montreal by Stefan
Tadamon!: A number of media articles were published this last week in response
to an ABC news report claiming that Hezbollah is activating cells in Canada.
Wanted to first have your reaction to the claim put forward in this report
arguing that Hezbollah was planning to strike in North America; can you comment
on this possibility?
Ali Mallah: Based on mainstream information Hezbollah has never declared an
intention to have military actions be undertaken in Europe or North America. In
Lebanese terms Hezbollah is a political party and movement, with elected MPs
operating within the Lebanese government, in coalition with numerous other
political parties. After the resolution to the latest conflict in Lebanon, it
is clear that Hezbollah as a political party will be playing a major role in
the new Lebanese government.
Hezbollah as a political organization is part of the Lebanese social fabric.
Unfortunately in North America, in Canada, with a political shift to the right,
also a shift towards Israel, there has been increased negative media coverage
towards any groups or organizations both locally or internationally who take a
position against Israel's illegal occupation in Palestine or aggression towards
Tadamon!: Mainstream media in recent weeks has reasserted the official position
on Hezbollah from the Canadian government, which considers Hezbollah is a
terrorist organization. In many countries, also within the European Union,
Hezbollah is not considered a terrorist organization. Wondering your thoughts
on the recent wave of media coverage in Canada on Hezbollah, wondering if you
think that media reports have influenced popular understanding towards
Hezbollah in Canada?
Ali Mallah: Understanding the media reports in recent weeks is important.
Remember there was no debate within the Canadian Parliament on adding Hezbollah
to Canada's terror list. Personally remember statements in a meeting with the
former Liberal Foreign Affairs Minister Bill Graham, who explained that the
government was coming under intense pressure to add Hezbollah to the terror
list from pro-Israel organizations in the country.
Clearly it would be beneficial to have a debate on Hezbollah in the open. Today
it's clear that the current government isn't interested in having a real debate
on the issues. Canada's current government is simply feeding into stereotypes
surrounding the Middle East and the Arab and Muslim world.
Canada's government is creating cases against Muslims in Canada that simply
have no legal basis.
Let's refer to the case of the Toronto 18, a group of arrested, accused of
planning to commit terrorism in Canada. Until now none one from the Toronto 18
has been found guilty of any charge, while seven have already been released on
bail. Mentioning this to illustrate that there are serious holes in the
Canadian government's current policies in this regard. Today it is hard to find
truth in the government line.
Going back to the original point concerning Hezbollah, it should also be
mentioned that in recent days the British government has placed Hezbollah's
entire military wing on the terrorist list. This is an unfortunate development.
In France the current government didn't comment on the change in British
policy, while it should be mentioned that the French government has on a couple
of occasions extended invitations to representatives of Hezbollah for talks.
Tadamon!: Can you describe you reaction the first time that you read the recent
wave of media reports on Hezbollah in Canada?
Ali Mallah: Anxiety, worry and anger. These feelings came forward because many
Lebanese people have been questioned and harassed by CSIS and other
intelligence agencies in Canada, especially after the assassination of
Hezbollah commander Imad Mughniyeh in Syria. Many visits happened after this
After seeing these recent media reports many now worry, as it's highly possible
that CSIS will now conduct numerous unwelcome visits within the Lebanese
community as a result of these media reports.
The Canadian Arab Federation has written a very strongly worded letter to the
Stockwell Day, Minister of Public Safety, who is responsible for CSIS,
expressing our deep concern that these unfounded media reports on Hezbollah
will result in the targeting of the Arab and Lebanese community.
Tadamon!: Could you explain the responses that you have received from within
the Arab community, as the Canadian Arab Federation, in response to these media
Ali Mallah: People feel frustrated, people feel singled out. People are
wondering if these recent media reports are an attempt to create an opening for
another round of questioning by government agencies within the Arab and
Lebanese community, similar to 2006. It's well known within the Lebanese
community that there are no Hezbollah operations in Canada and that it is
highly, highly unlikely that any action from Hezbollah would ever take place in
Multiple times it was stated by leaders in Hezbollah in Lebanon that their
conflict isn't with Jewish groups or organizations or people around the world,
but that the conflict is with Israel as a colonial state and an occupying
These recent media reports aren't sitting well within the Arab or Lebanese
community in Canada. People are anxious and awaiting a response to these
reports through unwelcome visits by CSIS.
Tadamon!: For one week now reports that Hezbollah plans to open operations in
Canada has been bouncing between major media networks in Canada. Many within
the Lebanese community have expressed fear that in the shadow of media reports
the government now views the entire Lebanese Shiite community as directly
connected to Hezbollah, can you speak about this fear?
Ali Mallah: Hezbollah as a political party, as a political group enjoys wide
popular support in Lebanon and the Middle East. Many view Hezbollah in the
Middle East as a symbol of integrity and dignity after the war in 2006 and
after the failures of the Oslo Accords, which Hezbollah openly opposed.
It has to be made clear that although people are sympathetic to Hezbollah, you
simply wont find people within the Lebanese community working as members of
Hezbollah in Canada, it is critical to make this distinction. Although there is
moral support there is no direct affiliation.
Tadamon!: Could you offer your thoughts on the way in which the media portrayed
this particular story, the way that the Canadian media picked-up the ABC news
report. Do you have any thoughts, reflections or critiques?
Ali Mallah: It's an ongoing struggle with the media in Canada, especially after
9/11. As the Canadian Arab Federation we have expressed concern with every
major media outlet in the country concerning unfair portrayal of Arabs and
Muslims in the press.
Often the media produces such reports, such as these recent stories on
Hezbollah, without the community having an opportunity to present another point
of view. Concerning the Arab community and the Middle East in general the media
is often bias against us.
As the Canadian Arab Federation we have met with the Toronto Star, the Globe
and Mail, the CBC and even the National Post to express these concerns. It is
clear that the media often portrays Arabs and Muslims in Canada as outsiders,
as removed from society, the media portrays us often in unwelcoming ways.
Clearly the Canadian Arab Federation has a major issue with the way that the
mainstream media portrays us, to understand more on this people should read
Casting Out: The Eviction of Muslims from Western Law and Politics, by Sherene
Despite this reality we will not sit back, we will continue to fight for our
rights, while insisting on the values we believe in.
More information about the Imc-beirut