[Imc-uk-features] Atzmon issue at the Indymedia Gathering

[maqui]

Hello

On Wednesday, February 6, 2008, at 10:18  pm, Shiar wrote:

> Just to say that i agree with tony.

Me too actually. I think Greenstein has already used enough (and often 
unwanted) space in our in-boxes as to take more time on the already 
very full meeting's agenda. I think a 'rare' network meeting should 
concentrate on the inner-issues of Indy, as well as on sorting out the 
back-office(s) with as little outside noise as possible.

Imho the real issue(s) over editorial matters is not about whether 
Greeinstein (or Atzmon) is/are right or not, but about creating process 
and guidelines that will enable IMC-Uk to deal with disagreements such 
as the ones recently in the features-list. I also agree with tony when 
he says that Greeinsteins attitude over all this has been 'far from 
constructive'.

Cheers
maqui

>
> -- 
> Shiar
>
> On Wed, February 6, 2008 1:10 pm, Tony wrote:
>> Hello
>>
>> Personally i do not think this would be appropriate as we want to
>> have the discussion about Indymedia and our response to the issues in
>> relation to our project - not from Greenstiens perspective. Added to
>> this his attitude so far has been far from constructive - and i doubt
>> has helped his position one bit!
>>
>> If we allowed his reading - we would need the counter - then off we
>> go again... We know the issues at stake and have requested along time
>> ago he stay out of it.
>>
>> cheers tony
>>
>> At 16:30 -0800 5/2/08, thewallmustfall at riseup.net wrote:
>>> A whle back Tony Greenstein asked me if he could write something to 
>>> be
>>> read out at the Indymedia gathering summing up his views on the 
>>> issue of
>>> Gilad Atzmon posting on the newswire
>>>
>>> What do people think??
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>>  How Indymedia UK became a safe haven for Anti-Semitism (390689)
>>>>  by Tony Greenstein - inaccurate/non news/complaint about moderation
>>>>
>>>>  ftp
>>>>
>
>
>
> --
> Indymedia United Kollektives editorial: features and wire moderation
> http://lists.indymedia.org/mailman/listinfo/imc-uk-features
>